Behind The Velvet Rope Series | 05

The Index Fund Paradox: What Your S&P 500 Fund Can't Own

Written by Blaise Stevens

MBA, CFP®, AIFA®, CLU®, ChFC®

Index fund investing is one of the most important ideas in modern finance. John Bogle, the founder of Vanguard and creator of the first index fund available to individual investors, demonstrated that most active managers do not beat the market net of fees and that investors are better served by simply owning the market at minimal cost. That insight has probably created more wealth for ordinary Americans than any single idea in the history of investing.

This post is not an argument against index funds. It is an argument that the most widely owned index in America has developed a specific blind spot, that the blind spot is a consequence of its rules rather than an accident, and that most investors who own it have never been told any of this.

When the first version of this post was published in March 2026, the argument was necessarily theoretical. Five months later it is not. This update rewrites the piece around what actually happened.

The Simple Logic of the Index Fund

An S&P 500 index fund owns every company in the S&P 500, weighted by market capitalization. When Apple is worth 7% of the index, your fund owns Apple at that weight. When a new company enters the index and an old one leaves, your fund rebalances automatically. You collect the market return and avoid the drag of an active manager guessing wrong on individual stocks.

The underlying assumption is that the S&P 500 represents a reasonably complete picture of the most important, most valuable businesses in the American economy. For most of the index’s history, that assumption was close enough to true that it did not matter much.

It is becoming less true every year. And the reason is not that index providers are asleep. It is that the S&P 500 screens for things other providers do not, for reasons that are defensible on their own terms and that have a cost.

The Economy Is Still Moving Faster Than the S&P 500

Anthropic raised $65 billion in May at a post-money valuation of $965 billion, making it the most valuable AI startup in the world, having overtaken OpenAI. It is not in the S&P 500. OpenAI is valued at approximately $852 billion, confirmed by an employee tender offer completed in August. It is not in the S&P 500. Stripe was valued at $159 billion in a February tender offer. It is not in the S&P 500.

Sources: Anthropic, "Anthropic raises $65B in Series H funding at $965B post-money valuation," May 28, 2026; Bloomberg and TechCrunch, OpenAI $7 billion employee tender offer, August 10, 2026; Bloomberg and Axios, Stripe tender offer, February 24, 2026.

Those three carry a combined private valuation just under $2 trillion. Each has now taken a step toward the exit. Anthropic filed a confidential draft S-1 on June 1; as of this writing no public prospectus has been filed, and press reports point to an October listing at a valuation near $2 trillion, roughly double its last private mark. OpenAI announced its own confidential filing on June 8, and on August 19 its chief financial officer told employees the company would be public in 2027, if not sooner.

Sources: Anthropic, confidential draft S-1 announcement, June 1, 2026; Fortune, reported October listing and valuation, August 13, 2026; TechCrunch, OpenAI confidential filing, June 8, 2026; CNBC, OpenAI chief financial officer on 2027 timing, August 19, 2026. Status as of August 24, 2026. Reported IPO timing and valuations are from press coverage and have not been confirmed by either company.

Nor is the exit always a listing. On August 14, SpaceX closed a $60 billion all-stock acquisition of Anysphere, the maker of Cursor, reported as the largest startup exit on record. Public shareholders own that asset now, having paid for it with roughly 391 million newly issued shares and the dilution that came with them. What they did not get was any part of the run from seed round to $60 billion, all of which happened privately.

Sources: SpaceX Form 8-K, August 14, 2026; TechCrunch, August 15, 2026.

Vanguard’s reading is that this is not a temporary anomaly waiting to be resolved by the next IPO cycle, but a structural change in how and when companies access public capital. Vanguard’s August 2026 private equity outlook puts the median age of a company at IPO at roughly six years in the 1980s, rising to a recent peak of fifteen years in 2022, while the population of venture-backed companies worth $1 billion or more grew from 228 companies worth a combined $800 billion in 2016 to roughly 1,700 companies worth $8.6 trillion. On that view, the early growth arc now happens largely in private markets.

Source: Vanguard, "Why more growth happens before the IPO," private equity outlook, August 2026. These figures differ from other widely used IPO age datasets and should be read as one firm’s analysis rather than a settled figure.

What June Actually Showed

SpaceX went public on June 12, pricing 555.6 million shares at $135 to raise $75 billion, rising to roughly $86 billion once the overallotment was exercised. It was the largest initial public offering in history. The stock closed the first day at $161.11, up 19%, putting its market capitalization near $2.1 trillion, more than Anthropic, OpenAI, and Stripe are worth combined. For context, SpaceX had been privately valued at approximately $1.25 trillion in February after combining with xAI.

Sources: TechCrunch and NPR, SpaceX IPO pricing, June 11, 2026; CNBC, "SpaceX market cap tops $2 trillion," June 12, 2026; Bloomberg and CNBC, SpaceX-xAI combination, February 2026.

Here is the part that matters for anyone who owns an S&P 500 fund. On June 4, eight days before the offering, S&P Dow Jones Indices published the results of a consultation on the treatment of megacap companies and left the eligibility criteria for the S&P 500 unchanged. Its stated position was that exceptions to the financial viability, seasoning, and investable weight factor requirements should not be granted solely based on market capitalization. It did relax the float requirement for its broader total-market indexes, but not for the S&P 500. The S&P 500 requires positive GAAP net income from continuing operations in the most recent quarter and across the sum of the most recent four consecutive quarters. SpaceX reported a net loss of $4.94 billion in 2025 on revenue of $18.67 billion, and lost a further $4.28 billion in the second quarter of 2026 alone. It did not qualify, and it will not qualify until it produces sustained profitability on that basis.

Sources: S&P Dow Jones Indices, "Consultation on Treatment of MegaCap Companies – Results," June 4, 2026; SpaceX Form S-1 and subsequent quarterly filings with the SEC.

The other major index providers took a different view, and moved quickly. The CRSP US Total Market Index added SpaceX on June 18, six days after the debut, using an existing fast-track provision. Russell added it to the Russell 1000 on June 29, MSCI to its US indexes in late June, and Nasdaq to the Nasdaq-100 effective July 7, having eliminated its minimum float requirement outright for a company that had listed only about 4% of its shares.

So this is not a story about index funds being unable to reach SpaceX. Most of them reached it within weeks. It is a story about one index, and it happens to be the one that anchors the American retirement system.

Sources: Morningstar, "How index funds are adapting to mega-IPOs," 2026; 401(k) Specialist, July 10, 2026; Nasdaq, Nasdaq-100 index announcement, June 26, 2026. Weightings are as of the dates reported and change with market movement.

The Crowding-Out Problem, Partly Confirmed

The March version of this post predicted that the index would arrive late, picking these companies up at their debut price after the private wealth creation had already happened. That is close to what happened, and the six-day turnaround at CRSP makes the point more sharply than a slow one would have. Even the fastest index in the market bought at post-IPO prices. Speed was never the constraint. Eligibility is.

The investors who owned SpaceX privately, whether through an early round, a later growth round, or a secondary purchase, captured the compounding that carried the company to its debut. The institutional buyers who were allocated shares in the offering got them at the offering price. The retail buyer who could get an allocation, or who bought that first morning, paid somewhere in the opening day’s range. The total-market index fund investor got a position on June 18, six days later, at a weight below 0.2%. The S&P 500 index fund investor got nothing at all, and will get nothing until SpaceX clears the earnings test, which reporting suggests is unlikely before the middle of 2027.

That is the ordering, and it is worth being precise about which wall did the work. Four index providers crossed the public-private boundary within three weeks of the listing. One committee’s earnings screen kept the S&P 500 on the other side of it.

What Happened Next Is Equally Instructive

On its third trading day, June 16, the stock touched an intraday high of $225.64. From there it fell hard. It broke below the $135 offering price on July 15, the first time it had done so, and bottomed at $104.83, roughly 54% below the peak. The recovery came in the first week of August. On August 6 the first lockup tranche released 911.5 million shares without the selloff investors had feared, and the same day Tesla and SpaceX announced Terafab, a joint AI chip fabrication plant in Texas backed by an initial $16.8 billion commitment. The stock rose 6% that session and another 16% the next, and closed back above its offering price on August 10.

It has not settled. A second tranche of roughly 319 million shares unlocked on August 20 and the stock traded back below $135 intraday. It closed at $136.97 on August 21, a market capitalization near $1.86 trillion on roughly 13.6 billion shares outstanding. Larger unlocks follow in November and December, and the next Nasdaq-100 rebalance on September 21 could raise its index weight as the float expands.

Sources: CNBC and Bloomberg, SpaceX shares fall below IPO price, July 15, 2026; CNBC, first lockup expiration, August 6, 2026; TechCrunch, Tesla and SpaceX Terafab announcement, August 6, 2026; CNBC, SpaceX reclaims $135 IPO price, August 10, 2026; Yahoo Finance, second tranche unlock, August 20, 2026. Closing price as of August 21, 2026.

Two things follow from this, and they point in opposite directions. The first is that the entire private run, and the first week of the public one, happened before any index fund held a share. That is one realized outcome in one security over ten weeks, not a return series, and it says nothing about what the next such company will do. The second is that the public market did something private markets do not do, which is reprice the asset violently and in public within weeks. A private secondary mark does not fall 50% on a Tuesday, though not because private assets are inherently less volatile. Depending on entry price, fee structure, and how the vehicle carries its marks, an investor holding SpaceX privately through the summer might have taken a comparable economic loss without ever seeing it on a statement.

It is worth stating the uncomfortable half plainly. The S&P 500 investor who got nothing also avoided the drawdown. Someone who bought at the first-day close of $161.11 is down roughly 15% as of August 21; someone who got the $135 offering price is up about 1.5%. Measured from any entry an index fund could actually have achieved, exclusion has so far been worth money rather than costing it.

Anyone who tells you that private market access is a one-way improvement is selling something.

What the Advocates Are Saying

Brad Gerstner, founder of Altimeter Capital, has made this problem a central part of his public work. Altimeter invests in private companies, including Anthropic, and would benefit from broader retail access to them; his argument should be read with that in mind. His argument starts from participation. Gallup’s 2025 survey puts U.S. stock ownership at 62% of adults once retirement accounts are counted, which leaves roughly four in ten with no equity stake at all in the companies shaping the next economy, concentrated among younger and lower-income households.

His initiative, Invest America, became law as part of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in 2025 and was implemented as the Trump Accounts program. It launched operationally on July 4, 2026, creating tax-advantaged accounts that any child under 18 may hold, with a $1,000 Treasury seed reserved for those born between January 1, 2025 and December 31, 2028. Families and employers may contribute up to a combined $5,000 a year on top of that, with employer contributions excludable from income up to $2,500 within the cap.

The administration reported more than 7 million accounts opened as of late July, across all eligible ages; about 1 million families had claimed the $1,000 for a qualifying newborn. Gerstner has predicted $100 billion in additional private contributions over the next twelve months.

Sources: Gallup, "What percentage of Americans own stock?," 2025; U.S. Department of the Treasury, "Trump Accounts: The Defining Policy of America’s 250th Anniversary," July 2026; CPA Practice Advisor, July 29, 2026; Fox Business, Gerstner on corporate contributions, July 8, 2026. Participation estimates vary considerably depending on whether retirement accounts are counted.

The design carries an irony. The Treasury seed is invested in an S&P 500 index fund, and proposed rules issued on August 20 would require eligible investments to be low-cost and broadly indexed. A newborn funded on July 4 owns, by default, precisely the index that could not include the largest listing in history.

Sources: U.S. Department of the Treasury, July 1, 2026, and proposed eligible-investment regulations, August 20, 2026. At launch all contributions are invested in the State Street SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF (SPYM), the default within a five-fund lineup.

Chamath Palihapitiya has raised a related concern from the supply side. In April he warned companies planning to list after SpaceX to move quickly, arguing that public markets cannot absorb trillions of dollars of new issuance in short order. He returned to the theme on a June episode of the All-In podcast devoted to the private stock market boom.

Sources: Benzinga, Chamath Palihapitiya on post-SpaceX IPO sequencing, April 6, 2026; All-In Podcast, "Inside the Private Stock Market Boom: SpaceX, Anthropic, OpenAI & the Rise of Secondaries," June 7, 2026.

Washington Is Responding, Slowly

Following Executive Order 14330 in August 2025, the Department of Labor proposed a rule on March 30, 2026 that would give 401(k) plan fiduciaries a process-based safe harbor when selecting designated investment alternatives. The proposal was prompted by the order’s directive on alternative assets, but as drafted it is not limited to them. A fiduciary that objectively evaluates six specified factors — expected performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, benchmarking, and complexity — would be presumed to have satisfied its duty of prudence. The comment period closed on June 1, 2026, and the rule is not final. Running alongside it is Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, which the Supreme Court agreed in January 2026 to hear, and which will address what a plaintiff must plead to challenge a fiduciary who put alternatives in a target-date fund. That decision may shape behavior more than the safe harbor does.

Sources: Gibson Dunn and Morgan Lewis client alerts on the proposed rule, 2026; Alston & Bird, "DOL Proposal and Supreme Court Review Poised to Clarify Fiduciary Standards for Alternatives in 401(k) Plans," April 2026.

A safe harbor for fiduciaries is not a mandate, a product, or a good idea for any particular participant. It lowers a legal barrier. Whether the resulting products are worth owning, at what fees and on what liquidity terms, is a separate question that will take years to answer.

What This Is Not

Index funds do exactly what they claim. The limitation described here is not a flaw in how they track their benchmark; it is a consequence of one benchmark’s eligibility rules, which its administrator reviewed in June and chose to keep.

The premise itself is also genuinely contested, and by the same firm cited earlier. In March 2025 Vanguard published research titled "Are companies really staying private for longer? No." Examining IPOs from 2003 through 2024, it found that the average age of a company at IPO had not changed materially and that the investable universe of public companies had remained stable, with the apparent decline in listed company counts driven largely by microcaps that were never meaningfully investable. In fairness, the two papers are not quite in direct conflict: the earlier one measures average age across the whole investable universe of IPOs, the later one the median age of venture-backed listings over a much longer window. But that is the point. The answer depends heavily on which companies you count and over what period, and anyone citing a single figure with confidence, including me, is choosing a frame.

Source: Vanguard, "Are companies really staying private for longer? No," March 7, 2025.

There is also real risk in the alternative. Not every private company with a billion-dollar valuation will become the next Amazon. Many will fail. Private market investments carry genuine risk of permanent capital loss, along with illiquidity, long lockups, and wide dispersion between top and bottom quartile managers. A broadly diversified public portfolio manages a great deal of that through breadth and daily pricing. Fees deserve particular attention too: in the retail-accessible vehicles now being marketed, the layered cost structure has historically absorbed a large share of whatever illiquidity premium the asset class produced. A gap in access is not the same thing as a gap you can profitably cross.

The Honest Conclusion

For most investors, most of the time, a low-cost index fund portfolio remains an excellent foundation.

But it is worth knowing what your particular foundation excludes, and the first question that raises is not about private markets. It is about index selection. A total-market fund held SpaceX within a week of listing; an S&P 500 fund still does not. Most investors have never consciously made that choice. Revisiting it is not free either, since switching funds can realize capital gains in a taxable account and many retirement plan menus do not offer the alternative at all, but it is worth knowing which one you hold and why.

The separate question, for investors with the appropriate qualifications, time horizon, and risk tolerance, is whether any part of the private phase belongs in a portfolio at all. The institutions that have allocated there for decades did not do it out of irrationality. They did it because they understood something the conventional wisdom does not fully capture: the best opportunities are not always the most accessible ones. Whether the versions of that access now being marketed to individuals are worth their cost is a different question again, and one worth asking hard.

With Anthropic reported, though not confirmed, to be targeting an October listing, the next test of all this may arrive within months rather than years. It is worth understanding now where your portfolio will stand when it does.

Ready to think through whether your current portfolio construction reflects this shift in market structure?

I'm Happy to Have that Conversation.

Blaise Stevens

MBA, CFP®, AIFA®, CLU®, ChFC®

Looking for More From the Behind the Velvet Rope Series?

For most of modern market history, the IPO was the starting line. Today, much of a company’s growth story is over before it ever reaches a public exchange. In this five-part series, Blaise Stevens, CFP®, examines the structural shift toward private markets: why companies are staying private longer, how institutions like the Yale endowment have invested behind the velvet rope for decades, what is really happening inside the private credit boom, how accredited investors can realistically access these markets today, and what your index fund, by design, cannot own.

When Compute Becomes an Asset Class

When Compute Becomes an Asset Class

The world now spends more building data centers than it does finding new oil, yet compute has never had a futures market. That is changing as CME Group brings the first compute futures to market. History shows that when a new asset class is born, individual investors are rarely first through the door. Here is what that means for the private market funds you may already own.

Stripe: The Case Study in Staying Private

Stripe: The Case Study in Staying Private

Stripe processed $1.9 trillion in payments last year and carries a $159 billion valuation, yet it still has no plans to go public. This summer it even tried to buy PayPal without a ticker symbol of its own. Blaise Stevens explains why Stripe chooses to stay private and what that choice means for investors who want access to the growth.

How Accredited Investors Can Actually Access Private Markets

How Accredited Investors Can Actually Access Private Markets

Private market access has changed dramatically in the past five years. Structures that once required eight-figure minimums are now available to accredited investors through interval funds, BDCs, platforms like iCapital, and secondary markets. In Post 4 of Behind the Velvet Rope, Blaise Stevens, walks through the realistic options, the tradeoffs, and how to think about sizing.

Private Credit: What Is Actually Going On Right Now

Private Credit: What Is Actually Going On Right Now

Private credit’s headline default rate says 1 to 2%. A broader measure says 5.8%. In this installment of Behind the Velvet Rope, Blaise Stevens looks at what is really happening inside the $3.5 trillion private credit market in 2026: hidden defaults, paper income, self-graded valuations, and the corners of the market that may still hold up.

What Institutions Have Known for Decades: The Yale Endowment Story

What Institutions Have Known for Decades: The Yale Endowment Story

In 1985, Yale’s endowment looked like a very large 60/40 portfolio. Then a 31-year-old named David Swensen took over as CIO and spent the next three decades turning $1.3 billion into $42.3 billion. His core insight was simple and counterintuitive: liquidity is a cost, not a feature. This post breaks down the Yale Model, why it worked, why it has become harder to replicate, and what the illiquidity premium means for individual investors today.

Why Wealth Is Being Created Before Companies Go Public

Why Wealth Is Being Created Before Companies Go Public

There used to be a bell-ringing moment when regular investors got their shot at the future: the IPO. That moment still exists, but for most investors it now comes too late. The biggest companies of our era are doing their pre-IPO wealth creation behind a velvet rope—and here’s what that means for your portfolio.

This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. The opinions expressed are those of Strategic Advisory Partners as of the date published and are subject to change without notice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

Any statistics or third-party information referenced are believed to be reliable but cannot be guaranteed for accuracy or completeness. Examples provided are illustrative and for illustrative purposes only and do not represent actual client experiences or guaranteed outcomes.

Retirement planning strategies should be evaluated based on an individual’s unique financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance. Before making financial decisions, individuals should consult with their financial, tax, and legal professionals.

Strategic Advisory Partners is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. More information about Strategic Advisor Partners’ investment advisory services can be found in its Form ADV Part 2 or Form CRS, which is available upon request.

3819 Lawndale Dr.

Greensboro, NC 27455

(336) 790-2560